“The Summer I Turned Pretty” Season 2 Finale: Unraveling the Mystery – Does Belly Choose Conrad?

“The Summer I Turned Pretty” Season 2 has delivered an engaging storyline, allowing us to dive deeper into the emotions and complexities of the main characters – Belly, Conrad, and Jeremiah. Unlike the first season, which primarily focused on mushy moments, Season 2 delves into the gravity of the situations these protagonists find themselves.in This recap and explainer will take you through the events of the season and provide insights into Belly’s journey.

Saving The Beach House

In Season 2, we hoped to see the exploration of Belly’s relationship with Conrad, but instead, she finds herself in the same predicament as Season 1 – torn between Conrad and Jeremiah. However, Belly’s character has grown since Season 1, and having achieved what she wanted, she now understands Conrad’s true self.

They share a mutual attraction, similar beliefs about love, and commitment to their loved ones. Despite their confession of feelings, Belly holds off on officially dating Conrad out of concern for Jeremiah. Conrad, on the other hand, seeks his brother’s blessing to be with Belly.

Although Jeremiah is unaware of their self-restraint, giving approval to his brother dating the girl he still has feelings for isn’t easy. Despite the complexity, Belly and Conrad start dating, yet their relationship is overshadowed by Susannah’s condition. Conrad’s preoccupation prevents him from fully being present for Belly, causing her to question if he truly wants to be with her.

A moment of insecurity at the prom and witnessing Conrad seek solace with another girl at his mother’s funeral leads to a breakup. Belly’s heartbreak prompts her to reconnect with Jeremiah, leading them to search for Conrad at the beach house. Despite Julia’s plan to sell the house, a series of conversations helps her embrace new beginnings, resulting in Adam Fisher buying the house.

Does Belly Go With Conrad?

Throughout the season, Belly reflects on her relationships with Jeremiah and Conrad, gaining a deeper understanding of their individual traits. Conrad, once an idealized love interest, reveals his inability to be emotionally available during challenging times. In contrast, Jeremiah proves his reliability and supportiveness. When fighting to prevent the beach house from being sold, Belly recognizes the stark differences between the boys.

This realization, along with Conrad’s acknowledgment of his feelings for Belly, doesn’t alter her decision. She confesses her love to Jeremiah and solidifies their relationship while Conrad gracefully steps back. The season concludes with Belly embracing new possibilities and her true self, supported by Jeremiah.

Final Thoughts

It’s crucial to remember that Belly, Conrad, and Jeremiah are flawed individuals, navigating complex emotions and circumstances as teenagers. Their confusion is understandable, given the burdens they carry at such young ages. Despite occasional annoyances with the characters, “The Summer I Turned Pretty” Season 2 remains one of the sweetest series to watch this year.


“The Summer I Turned Pretty” Season 2 delves deeper into the emotions and challenges faced by Belly, Conrad, and Jeremiah. Despite the initial obstacles, Belly and Conrad attempt a relationship, but turmoil stemming from Susannah’s condition leads to their breakup. Belly’s journey eventually leads her to choose Jeremiah, appreciating his unwavering support. The season concludes with Belly embracing new beginnings and discovering her true self, making it a delightful and heartfelt watch.